Indian Rocks Beach Fights Back Against Vacation Rental Lawsuit

cliggittvaluation • March 19, 2025

On February 27, 2025, the Indian Rocks Beach City Commission voted 4-1 to reject a proposed settlement in a lawsuit from AP6, a company that owns a vacation rental property at 455 20th Ave. The lawsuit claims that the city’s 2023 short-term rental ordinance, which limits rentals to 10 guests, has caused a huge drop in the property’s value—about $2.65 million, according to court documents. The company argues that the city’s new rules are infringing on their property rights under Florida's Bert Harris Private Property Rights Protection Act. The Commission’s decision to continue fighting the lawsuit shows just how much tension there is between property owners and local governments over short-term rental regulations.


For local residents, the situation has sparked heated debates, especially over the rise of large "party houses" in formerly quiet neighborhoods. While the property owners are upset about the financial impact of the new rules, many residents are glad to see the city standing firm. “Your job as a commissioner is to represent your constituents,” said one resident, emphasizing the concerns of people living nearby. It’s clear that the local community is divided, with some in favor of more regulation and others defending their right to rent out their properties as they see fit.


For those in commercial real estate, this lawsuit highlights the growing importance of understanding local regulations, especially for vacation rental properties. As cities like Indian Rocks Beach crack down on short-term rentals, it could affect the value of these properties and their potential for income. This case could set a big precedent for how future cases like this are handled, so it’s important for investors and property owners to stay informed about how these regulations are shaping the market.


With mediation set for later this month, it seems like both sides are still digging in their heels. On one hand, property owners want to protect their investments, while on the other, residents want to keep their neighborhoods from turning into tourist hotspots. As local advocate John Pfanstiehl put it, “Legislators have woken up to the damage STRs (short-term rentals) do in residential neighborhoods.” It’ll be interesting to see how this case plays out and what it means for other cities and commercial real estate in the future


Source : Tampa Bay Times


Thank you for your interest. Have questions regarding the local market? Navigate the Real Estate Market with confidence, and contact us at Cliggitt Valuation for your appraisal, consulting, and valuation needs today.


Mike Cliggitt, MAI, MRICS, CCIM

813.405.1705 | 863.661.1165 - Direct Lines

findvalue@cliggitt.com

Appraisal & Valuation Markets


SHARE CONTENT

By cliggittvaluation July 25, 2025
A well-known corner of South Tampa is getting a new lease on life. The property at 2616 S. MacDill Avenue—formerly home to the popular eateries Datz and Dough—is undergoing a complete transformation led by Three Oaks Hospitality. The new concept, 1983, is scheduled to open its doors in mid-August. Three Oaks, the hospitality and development group behind successful Tampa Bay ventures like Armature Works, The Pearl, Ciro’s, Steelbach, and Ro, acquired the site in 2023 and has since begun a creative reimagining of the space. The 150-seat restaurant will introduce a sports-forward, social dining experience with an upscale 1980s-inspired aesthetic. The adjacent Dough space will become a retro arcade, paying homage to iconic video games of the past—think Pac-Man and Galaga—while the restaurant itself will offer a menu that ranges from sushi and salads to French dips and classic wings. The design will incorporate vintage sports memorabilia and a preppy flair reminiscent of 1980s fashion and culture. The project’s name, 1983, reflects the birth year of twin brothers Charles and Kyle Bruck, co-founders of Three Oaks. One thing that isn’t changing? The landmark marquee sign out front, which locals may remember for its witty one-liners. It’s being preserved and will continue to feature playful messages as a nod to the building’s legacy. This revitalization adds to the continued momentum of redevelopment along the South MacDill corridor, a high-visibility commercial stretch in one of Tampa’s most established neighborhoods.
By cliggittvaluation July 21, 2025
Tampa residents have been waiting for high-speed rail service—and it’s starting to look like that dream could eventually become a reality. Brightline, the private passenger rail company already operating in South Florida, is officially making moves toward a Tampa expansion. The company recently requested $400 million in bonds to fund new stations and tracks across Florida, with Tampa named as one of the next planned stops. That funding would help push forward rail infrastructure connecting Tampa to Orlando and beyond. So… when can we actually expect to ride? The Not-So-Soon Timeline According to Hillsborough County Transportation Planning Organization executive director Johnny Wong, we might still be waiting another decade. Yep—ten years. Wong’s projection is based on information from a former Brightline executive, now with the Orlando Economic Partnership, who noted that Brightline will need to lay new rail along I-4 before the Tampa link becomes a reality. And since I-4 is currently undergoing a massive expansion that could take up to 20 years to complete, rail construction might not begin for a while. That said, there’s some hope. Governor DeSantis and the Florida Legislature have shown interest in speeding up the I-4 project, which would naturally help accelerate Brightline’s expansion timeline as well. Why Now? Ever since Brightline opened its Orlando station in 2023 (connecting to Miami), the buzz around a Tampa extension has only grown. With Central Florida’s population booming and I-4 getting more congested by the day, many are pushing for a faster, less stressful travel alternative. Last year, Mayor Jane Castor even floated 2029 as a possible opening year for the Tampa station. And with the recent bond request and local support—including a unanimous vote from Tampa City Council to allow Brightline to proceed with financing—the wheels are certainly turning. But There’s a Catch While Brightline has ambitious plans, the company is facing some financial headwinds. It fell about 30% short of its projected ridership last year, carrying roughly 2.8 million passengers. That drop came after eliminating popular $10 commuter passes, though those have since been brought back—and early signs show ridership recovering in South Florida. Despite operating at a $63 million loss last year and carrying $5.5 billion in debt, Brightline continues to grow. And Tampa appears to be next in line. Where Will the Station Go? A final location hasn’t been publicly announced, but city officials have hinted at a site in Tampa’s “greater downtown area,” possibly stretching from Ybor City to the Curtis Hixon Waterfront Park area. In May, Hillsborough County asked residents how they would get to the future station, and the majority said they’d drive or use ride-share services. That means the city will likely need to build a parking structure and invest in safer pedestrian and bike-friendly infrastructure. Respondents also voiced a desire for more public transit near the station, which could reignite conversations about expanding the TECO Line Streetcar into Tampa Heights. What If Brightline Doesn’t Make It? Even with the financial risks, there’s a silver lining. If Brightline lays the rail but later backs out, the infrastructure could still be used by another operator—think Amtrak or even a local transit authority. As Wong put it: “If we have assets for trains to go through Tampa to Orlando, I don’t see why there wouldn’t be competitors in that space.” Source: Tampa Bay Times Thank you for your interest. Have questions regarding the local market? Navigate the Real Estate Market with confidence, and contact us at Cliggitt Valuation for your appraisal, consulting, and valuation needs today. Mike Cliggitt, MAI, MRICS, CCIM 813.405.1705 | 863.661.1165 - Direct Lines findvalue@cliggitt.com Appraisal & Valuation Markets Questions about our blog? Contact our Director of Sales & Marketing, Sydney Avolt. Sydney Avolt 727.403.7418 - Direct Line sydney@cliggitt.com
By cliggittvaluation July 8, 2025
Florida’s property insurance market is finally showing signs of recovery in 2025, following several years of volatility. A combination of legislative reforms and a resilient response to recent storms has begun to steady both residential and commercial insurance rates. For those in the commercial real estate space, this shift offers a much-needed sense of predictability. With fewer surprise exclusions and more stable premium trends, stakeholders can breathe a little easier—even if hurricane season keeps everyone on alert. In this post, we break down the effects of the 2024 hurricane season, 2025 premium trends, key legislative changes, reinsurance market updates, and what these developments mean for property owners, brokers, and investors across the state. After the 2024 Hurricane Season: Resilience in Action
More Posts